For those who haven’t heard, New Jersey finally announced its average PARCC scores today.
This is my obligatory post-PARCC score announcement blog post.
Because I should write one.
The PARCC scores are just as anti-climatic as I expected.
It is hard to muster outrage.
I’m tired today.
I just don’t have it in me to react strongly.
And, frankly, these test scores don’t deserve much of a reaction.
Aggregate New Jersey test scores don’t tell us much at all.
Frankly, the broken-out scores won’t tell us much either. As Chris Tienken noted, we already know the results. They’re predicted by socio-economics and zip code.
Nevertheless, I’m sure the spin-game will begin. Has begun. *SIGH*
I will laugh about one thing. Our high school students didn’t do nearly as badly in math as the high school students in Illinois. After all, 2%-3% of NJ students taking high school math courses (Algebra I, Algebra II, or Geometry) exceeded expectations, but 0% of Illinois high school math students exceeded expectations. So IN YOUR FACE, Cubs fans. Go Mets!
Ok, I don’t really care (about either the Mets/Cubs game or the Illinois/New Jersey high school math comparisons). Sorry, Hubby. For your sake, I hope the Mets win. For my Chicago cousins, I hope the Cubs win.
My energy is low tonight.
I looked at the sample tests. I read about the sample tests. I saw how these tests set out to trick students by intentionally making all of the distractor answers plausible or even correct, but varying in supposed degrees of correctness.
The only way to ace these tests will be to prep, prep, prep for them all year long.
The tests will tell us nothing about real student achievement.
The tests will tell us nothing about which teachers are successful.
The tests will tell us nothing about which students were inspired to read a novel for the first time.
The tests will tell us nothing about which students were inspired to structure their persuasive writing more effectively after learning to master the logic necessary to write formal geometry proofs.
The tests will tell us nothing about which high school juniors sat up watching the presidential debates, out of the sense of responsibility that comes from knowing that they’d be voting for the first time.
The tests will tell us nothing about which students were inspired by a science project, or want to be astronauts because of Andy Weir’s book, The Martian.
So what is the point of getting worked up?
We all know what these tests measure.
They measure exactly what the politicians want them to measure.
They’ll be spun exactly how the media and the politicians feel like spinning them. And that spin will likely bear little to no relation to what is actually happening in our children’s classrooms and minds.
The only ways to know what is actually happening in our classrooms and our children’s minds is to ask our children, visit their classrooms, talk to their teachers, and review their homework.
The only way to hold our teachers and schools accountable is to involve ourselves in what is happening in our schools, and in the democratic process. We need to ask questions, not review aggregate answers. We need to visit classrooms, not sift through bureaucrats’ PowerPoint presentations.
And when there are problems we need to speak up, mobilize, and demand more of our schools. That’s what I did today — in a case of unfortunate coincidence on top of mishap on top of unfortunate coincidence, today my first grader had a sub for a sub for a sub. I kid you not. But the schools that succeed are the schools in which the parents can mobilize parent pressure to address those issues, at least with a demand for explicit and coherent communication from the administration, and proposals for reasonable solutions to address the underlying personnel issues that got us to this place. Our kids will be okay, because in one form or another, I’ve heard from half the parents in the class today on how we are going to address this issue (and I’m not even the class parent).
If we want to know how our schools are doing, we can start by looking at how parents are able to react to issues like the one my daughter’s class is currently facing. In communities where parents have resources and the democractic process is relatively intact, these issues will be addressed and the children will succeed.
Of course, all of our children deserve communities where parents have the bandwidth and social capital to put pressure on school administrations. Test scores will never make that happen. Instead, we should spend our energy on improving housing policy, inspiring diversity, and ensuring that all students have parents who are economically secure enough to be able to address what’s going on in their children’s classrooms. Those are the real fights. In a fair system, we wouldn’t have highly segregated public schools. We need to get rid of these tests so we can fight the real battles, like the battles against segregation and increasing inequality.
But just as our children’s educations are derailed each spring by testing, we parents and citizens and teachers and community members are also distracted by the testing, and the pernicious effects high-stakes tests have on our public schools.
Our children, our communities, our schools, and our teachers deserve more than an obsessive focus on these tests, tests, tests.
Our children, our communities, our schools, and our teachers deserve parents whose attention and commitment to their schools isn’t undermined by concerns that test scores indicate that their schools are failing.
But the only way to stop that obsessive focus on testing is to refuse to test.
The only way to stop test-prep curriculum is to make it unnecessary.
So I will continue to refuse these tests.
They tell us nothing about children, and nothing about teachers.
But in the meantime, there is no point in getting worked up about the results, when the results are meaningless.
And one day parent energy can be directed where it belongs, and not distracted by the testing sideshow created by our asinine national requirement that our children take annual high stakes standardized tests (and that teachers be fired and schools closed based on the outcomes of such tests).
Our kids deserve more than us spending our time on this nonsense.
We have better things to do. We have children to raise. We have a country to steer back onto the right track.
* * *
Lukewarm off the presses (sorry, it’s been a busy day, and really, who cares) check out the NJ PARCC scores yourself: